ManningCast vs. Pat McAfee: How Do Their Viewership Numbers Compare?
With ESPN reportedly bringing Pat McAfee’s own alternate broadcast to ESPN2, a comparison to the ManningCast’s numbers is inevitable. Here’s what’s actually known so far.
The only number currently available
Right now, there’s a viewership figure for just one side of this comparison: the ManningCast. On Monday night, it drew 705,000 viewers, compared to 23.2 million total viewers for the Broncos-Chiefs game — meaning the ManningCast captured roughly 3% of the audience watching the main broadcast. That figure comes from Andrew Marchand of The Athletic and reflects a pattern that’s held for a while: the ManningCast gets praised critically but hasn’t pulled a large audience.
Why there’s no McAfee number to compare yet
Pat McAfee’s alternate broadcast is a new addition to ESPN2’s Monday night lineup this year, and it’s set to air during weeks the ManningCast isn’t on. Since it hasn’t launched yet as of this reporting, there’s no viewership data for it to compare against the ManningCast’s 705,000.
Could they actually go head-to-head?
Yes — that possibility has been raised directly. Because ESPN2 will carry both shows on different weeks, a real comparison becomes possible once McAfee’s broadcast has aired a few times. There’s also a specific scenario worth watching: a potential side-by-side McAfee vs. ManningCast broadcast during the Super Bowl, which would put both shows in direct competition for the same audience on the same night.
Bottom line
As of now, only the ManningCast has a reported number. Whether McAfee’s show draws more, less, or similar viewership is unknown until it airs — worth checking back once ESPN2 has run both shows for a few weeks.




